Most commented posts

  1. Discreet Phone Sex Story — 16 comments
  2. Discreet Phone Sex with a Young Girl — 14 comments
  3. Brian Likes Big Tits and Asses — 14 comments
  4. Phone Sex Hotline for Perverts — 13 comments
  5. Kinky Phone Sex Milf — 13 comments

Author's posts

Phone Sex is the Perfect Career Choice for an Old Whore

phone sexI enjoy phone sex. Although I have a master’s degree in history and an undergrad degree in museum studies, I never utilized any of my degrees. Perhaps you could say I sort of use it because I am on the board of a local museum, but I got married and started a family. And never really pursued a career like I envisioned. But that’s not a complaint. I love the choices I’ve made in life. As a horny old woman, these choices have served me well.

But now that my offspring flew the coop, I have a lot of extra time on my hands. And sometimes I regret not pursuing a career after college. But then I go out and I find some boy toys to play with, and I realize the only job I want is fucking. Well not as a whore because I don’t want to charge money for something I enjoy doing. However, I find my phone bone career more rewarding than the museum job. Gives me a lot more time to go out into my community and pick up young studs to fuck.

This phone sex MILF went out to see if I could find any boys playing hooky in the park this morning. There’s a huge skateboard park nearby and often on nice fall days, a few boys will skip school and skateboard. I never see truant officers at the skateboard park. Why I do not know because they could always find some boys and girls there. But I guess I’m glad they don’t because that would mean I might not find some young studs as easily as I do there.

My Life Turned Out Better Than Expected

So, I put on some running pants that showed off my curvy ass and a sports bra that showed off my big tits, and I went running by the skateboard park. And I caught some flies with my honey trap. Some of those boys feel so emblazoned seeing a woman like me that they can’t control themselves. I had two young teenage boys telling me that no way could my husband take care of me like they could. Not even sure where they learned to think like, but they had my attention.

Plus, they appeared right. They don’t know that my older husband needs a little blue pill to get it up. So, I invited them back to my place to prove they could please me better than him. And they followed me like lost puppy dogs. When we got back to my brownstone, I undid their pants and started stroking and sucking them both. And I felt like such a greedy cock whore. I went two days with no dick. For a sexy MILF like me that’s like two years.

Perhaps, Being a Whore is the Career Path I Should Have Taken All Along

Although I didn’t talk to the boys much, we didn’t need to talk. We just needed to fuck. I got that first orgasm out-of-the-way with my mouth so that way they could fuck me hard and long. Those boys did not sell me worthless stock. When they told me they could fuck me better than my husband they did not lie. They double penetrated me while fondling my breasts and rubbing my clit. They might become my next phone sex addiction. Young hard cocks. Great stamina. Plus, they wanted to make me cum too.

So, I’m starting my shift today with a pussy and ass full of cum. I left it in there to give myself a little treat throughout the day. Plus, I figure there’s some cream pie lover out there who can’t wait to clean up my messy hairy pussy and ass. I might not have a career in museum work, but I have a career as a dirty old broad, and I love it.

My Phone Perverts Paradise is For All Your Kinks and Fetishes

phone perverts paradiseWelcome to my phone perverts paradise. All kinks and fetishes are welcome. I even have a few kinks and fetishes of my own. This likely will not come as a surprise to anybody, but I’m a cum junkie. I love the taste of cum. In the 80s as a young schoolgirl, I sucked a lot of cock. I seemed sexually mature way before my years. And I was. I masturbated sooner than any of my friends. Plus, I started blowing cock sooner than any of my friends. I’m pretty sure none of my friends seduce their daddy either.

My mom found me masturbating once with one of my stuffed animals and dragged me to a psychologist who labeled me a nymphomaniac. But I think the term now is simply sex addict. And I am a sex addict. However, I don’t risk anything for my phone sex addiction. My husband knows I like to fuck other people. And he never says no to that.

And I don’t just fuck anybody. I have standards. I like my men younger and in decent shape. They must smell good. So, I don’t need a fix so badly that I go down to the local homeless camps in New York City and fuck bums. But that might be hot to do one day. No just joking. I like my lovers clean.

This MILF Loves Boys Cum

I hated my mom after she shamed me for playing with my little bald kitty. Probably the last time I had a bald kitty. So, I seduced my father for revenge. But it took me a while to seduce my daddy. He honestly did not want to fuck his own daughter, no matter how hot I looked back then. But I’m persistent. And I always get my man.

Back then I liked my men older like most schoolgirls too. However, now I much prefer to play with younger men. They need an older woman to show them how to fuck. Plus, they need a woman with skill and patience. And I need cocks that can get hard at the drop of a dime and fuck me all night long.

Over the weekend, I seduced another young boy. One in a sea of young boys lucky enough to say they lost their virginity to me. This horny MILF fucks a lot of young boys. I plucked this boy right out of Central Park and brought him home to fuck. He barely talked, but he sported this big smile on his face like he could not believe any of this was real. But I assured him my hairy milf pussy, my big boobs, and my warm wet mouth were all real.

Boy Cock is What All Mature Women Crave

The boy did not need to know about my husband. He did not need to know that I fuck every young boy I can. Plus, he didn’t need to know about what I did as a schoolgirl. He just needed to know that I wanted his young cock and his young yummy cum. When I tell you that I have a fetish for cum, I mean, I have a fetish for boy cum. That shit tastes great. Sweet and sticky. Plus, chock full of protein to do a phone sex MILF body good.

I took that boy for a spin and milked his cock into my hairy snatch. I think four times. But it’s starting to get darker earlier now and he had to run home before his parents came looking for him. Although I didn’t think his mother or father would ever find him in my place. But I didn’t want the boy to get into any trouble either. Because I want that lad coming back to fuck this hairy milf again whenever he can.

A MILF Phone Sex Slut Needs a Hairy Pussy

milf phone sexMILF phone sex whores should sport hairy pussies. I never got on the bald is good bandwagon. But that’s because I believe a hairy pussy serves as a hallmark of a mature woman. Bald pussies belong on young girls. But mommies and MILFs should keep hairy beavers. And I love to show off my hairy cunt to young boys and watch their reactions. Most young boys love a hairy pussy even if they never see on in real life.

But I think a hairy pussy serves as a reminder of mommy‘s pussy. And I think that’s why so many younger guys appreciate some hair down below. Brings back fond memories of spying on mommy. My two stepsons and my two sons spied on my hairy pussy. Even back then most women shaved. I’m not sure when the craze started, but I think it began in the 90s. And it started with the porn community. Perhaps it provided easier cleanup and allowed you to see everything better down below.

But I’m bringing hairy pussies back. And Kim Kardashian appears to agree with me. She designed faux pube thongs for her lingerie line that sold out in less than 24 hours. Everyone wants a hairy snatch again. I think women believe that men prefer a shaved cunt. Women attempt to stay relevant by shaving their pussies and injecting Botox into their face. Or maybe getting a boob job later in life.

But not me. I remain all natural. No Botox in my face or lips. And I’m going to keep this hairy pussy. My sons believe a hairy pussy carries the scent of a woman. That musky scent. The smell, the look, and the taste of a hairy pussy might even be your next phone sex addiction.

My Hairy Pussy is a Great Surprise for Many Boys and Men

Recently, I fucked a boy my daughter used to babysit. A teenager now with inadequate social skills but he wanted my help. The help of a sexy MILF. He no longer wants to be a virgin. And he told me in the kitchen that he hoped I had a hairy pussy. Of course, as a teenage boy he watches porn on the Internet all the time. But he says he never sees a hairy pussy, even on mature women.

With my dark hair and mature age, he hoped my pussy would be hairy. He won the lottery. I showed him my hairy beaver. And he crawled to me, put his head between my legs, and started inhaling my bush like a bouquet of roses. Roses wished they smelled as good as my snatch. Before long, I instructed the lad how to lick my hairy pussy. And I think he’s a natural muff diver. He flossed with my beaver hair.

He truly seemed infatuated with my hairy pussy. I taught him how to eat pussy. And I showed him what a blowjob feels like. He filled me with a couple loads of cum, but I’m past my prime so I no longer can get pregnant. So, he could dump as many loads inside of me as he wanted. It turned into a great surprise, seeing him at my door.

Although I think he wanted me to cure him of his hairy pussy fetish, I’m pretty sure I just made that fetish stronger. This phone sex milf caters to all sorts of fetishes and kinks. But I never tend to cure your addiction. Instead, I usually take you deeper down the rabbit hole.

Orgy Fantasies Have Aroused Me Since I Was a Schoolgirl

orgy fantasiesDo you have orgy fantasies? I think most of us probably do. As a schoolgirl, I found fascination with swingers. Although most people would’ve thought I seemed too young to participate that never stopped me from wishing I could be a swinger too.

My parents never swung. But one of my friend’s parents did. During a sleepover one time while they thought me and Heather went to sleep, they invited some friends over for an orgy in their living room. And Heather and I heard the moaning, woke up and spied on them. So, ever since I’ve been consumed with swinger and orgy type fantasies.

My daughter and I talk about it all the time. I’ve done some gangbangs in frat houses on her college campus. But I always wanted an old-fashioned orgy with the girls and the boys getting their freak on together. My daughter thinks about those things too. She’s horny all the time just like her mother. My husband never denies me what I want. Even if his dick doesn’t work like it once did, if I wanted to have a swingers party, he wanted me to have one.

I Have Always Been Fascinated with Orgies

Early on in our marriage, we talked about group sex often. But we never made it happen. So, this weekend, I made it happen. My daughter helped. She came home to visit because she wanted to join the party. But she also wanted to help her mother clean the house and do the shopping for hors d’oeuvres and drinks.

We turned my Manhattan brownstone into a sex palace. We rearranged the family room so that it looked like a big bed. I even put a disco ball on the ceiling and played old disco albums on vinyl. I’m obsessed with all things from the 70s. So, I made my house look like a 70s swingers’ room.

However, I did not know that my daughter spiked the punch she made with Molly. Now I don’t need to be high to get my freak on. I’m a sex addict. But I guess it did help some of the other couples, especially the wives, loosen up so they could fuck whoever they wanted. I thought my husband would sit on the sidelines and masturbate while he watched the orgy. But he became too aroused watching me eat pussy and suck cock. And the visual worked better than Viagra because his cock looked harder than it did when we first got married.

I’m Bring Swinging Back, Baby

I love eating pussy. So does my husband. And he doesn’t even mind if he finds the cream of another man inside my pussy when he eats it. By the end of the orgy, my pussy looked full. I took a lot of cock. In my pussy, and in my ass too. My husband got some action. As well as our daughter. She loves older men. The Molly helped the wives loosen up. But I like to think my tongue helped too I’ve always gone both ways, but the Molly definitely helped me focus on those pussies while somebody fucked me from behind.

Saturday night in a brownstone in Manhattan, a bunch of couples got their freak on. Most of us in attendance qualify for AARP membership. But just because we’re old doesn’t mean we’re dead. This phone sex whore loves fucking till she can’t fuck anymore. I thanked my daughter too for the Molly because I know it helped loosen folks up to better enjoy the orgy. And my house still smells like pussy. Everybody enjoyed themselves. And everybody wants another orgy. So, I plan to make it happen again. I’m bringing swinging back baby.

Hot Phonesex Helps Men Like You Eat Your Own Cum

hot phonesexI love sharing hot phonesex stories with my callers. And I seem to have a diversified group of men who call me. I have sissy boys, panty, boys, cuckolds, boys you want to fuck their mother. And I have a few cream pie lovers too. As a mature woman, I can cater to many fetishes. Recently, I picked up a cum eater. I picked him up at a bar and brought him home to fuck. Although he did sport s big cock, and he appeared young, I think he leaned towards men, not a sexy woman like me.

Although I felt disappointed because I liked his cock, I also wanted to help him. He thinks about cock all the time. Does that sound like you? No judgment here. If you want to guzzle cum or get butt fucked or just dress like a girl and suck some cock, I will help you.

Christopher needed my help. I felt maternal towards the boy. His parents caught him jerking his meat to a Playgirl as a teen boy, and they shamed him. They even told him he would go to hell for looking at such pictures. So, I think he repressed his sexual desire for men. Now I don’t know if he’s gay or just bisexual. Or even if maybe he just leans towards being a sissy boy. It doesn’t matter to me if he wanted cock. I planned on helping him discover his true identity. I’m a safe place.

This Sexy MILF Loves All Sorts of Kinky Fetishes

The lad appeared tall and lanky with a big dick. So, I showed him how to suck his own dick. If you’ve got a big dick and you’re tall enough, you can do it too. He just needed the assistance of a phone sex MILF. I helped him rock his body into a beach ball position so that his cock hovered close to his face. I held my hands on his butt, leaning my body onto the back of his thighs to push his dick closer to his mouth.

This position allowed him to at least get the tip of his dick in his mouth. And I felt like a circus ringleader because I contorted this boy so he could suck his own cock. I shoved a finger in his ass, wiggled it around, and I knew when I found the right spot because he came all over his face. He grimaced at first, but then he started devouring his own cum.

Do You Want to Eat Your Own Cum?

He looked horrified and amazed at the same time. I don’t think he ever thought he would really taste his own jizz. Many men want to on calls, but they chicken out and hang up before I can encourage them to clean up the mess they made. But with Christopher, he could not wiggle out of cleaning up the mess he made. He blew chunks all over his face. But his dick never went soft, so I knew he liked it.

For his second cum swallow, I pegged him in the ass with a strap on. But I kept him in the same position so that his dick would hover over his face. Some men seem naturally flexible enough to do this on their own. Others need my help. That strapon found his G spot quickly though. Because once I hit that magic button, he started leaking like a faulty faucet. And eventually, I found the same spot again, and he exploded all over his face. I put my hands behind his head, cradling him up to lick his dick clean.

Two loads of cum, his own cum, I made him eat. Perhaps I would’ve preferred to fuck him because he did have a nice cock. But I can’t always get lucky. It felt good to help him out with his kinky phone sex fetish. So, let me ask you, have you ever wanted to eat your own cum too? No judgment for me. Just gentle encouragement to do what you know you want to do.

Hottest Phone Sex MILF Feeds Her Hubby Cum From Her Pussy

hottest phone sexThe hottest phone sex I think is with a mature kinky woman like me. Nothing is too taboo for me. I like to think that I’ve at least tried most things sexually. Because how do you know if you don’t like something if you don’t try it.

Something I discovered recently that I enjoy is feeding my husband my cream pie. I would not call my husband a traditional cuckold because he does have a decent size cock. But since he’s so much older than me, his cock needs a little blue pill to work. But we discovered that we could bypass Viagra with a few things. One, he likes to watch his wife fuck younger men. Two, he loves to clean up the mess they leave inside of his wife’s hairy pussy.

Last night, my husband watched me fuck a 19-year-old boy I picked up at the gym yesterday. And this boy sports a huge fucking cock. Plus, he seems to have a phone sex addiction for mature sexy women. I recently joined this gym because the LA fitness near me went out of business. And I’ve noticed the boy checking me out. I’ve been checking him out too. But yesterday morning, he made a move on me for the first time. So, I brought him home to fuck me in front of my husband.

Sometimes, My Husband Enjoys My Messy Pussy

At first, the boy seemed nervous. But I assured him that my old man just needs the right incentive to get an erection. And him fucking me would be the right incentive. I began with a blow job. That boy’s cock appeared massive because I had a hard time swallowing it all. And I have been sucking cock longer than he’s been on this planet. He loved my mature mouth on his dick. He even palmed the back of my head like a basketball. I looked out the corner of my eye and saw my husband tugging on his old dick. And he looked hard.

When my young stud started fucking me, I thought my husband might cum. So, I told him to sit on his hands and just enjoy the show. And my stud didn’t even realize he was there anymore. He just got lost in fucking my hairy pussy. But that boy pounded the shit out of me, and he made me come so fucking hard. He made me squirt more than once.

This young stud busted a huge load inside of me too. He told me no girl his age ever made him cum so hard. And I told him that’s because he’s never fucked a phone sex milf before. When he left, I summoned my husband over and I fed him my delicious cream pie. I swear that young stud left a bucket of cum inside of me. But My husband got every drop. Don’t knock it until you try it. All that cum just gave my hairy pussy extra flavor.

College Girls Phone Sex Gets Wild When Mommy Joins

college girls phone sexCollege girls phone sex I am no doubt past my prime to deliver. However, I have a senior in college, my youngest daughter, and she makes me feel like a coed again. In fact, she’s helping me relive my youth. I’ve always been a sexually wild person, even in my youth. but I never partied or experienced gang bangs in college or anything like that.

Of course, I could have been too busy seducing my professors to fool around with frat boys. But now that I’m older, frat boys seem perfect for me. I thought my daughter might come home for the weekend. But she had a big exam on Monday. So, her sexy mommy visited her.

My daughter took me to a Sig Ep party. My daughter is a Chi Omega. Honestly, when I went to college in the 80s, I never paid much attention to fraternities or sororities. I am not one to conform. So, I avoided them and did my own thing. But now that I am well passed my college years, I don’t care about appearances. I just want to have fun. And I can do that with my daughter when I visit her on campus.

My Daughter is a Slut Like Me

This phone sex MILF enjoys going wild with college girls and boys. Although I am not a big drinker, I can hold my own against any frat boy or sorority girl. But the fraternity party got wilder after they closed the doors to the public. Somebody put Molly in the beer. It did make the party a lot more interesting. Because I turned into a gangbang whore. My daughter too.

I think Molly resembles the poppers I did in the 80s. In college, I had friends who took poppers to relax and enjoy sex. The drug just let your inhibitions go to the wayside much like Molly does. But I think Molly has more of a kick. I never did a gang bang at a frat house on poppers. However, on Molly, that’s a different story.

I showed my daughter and her friends how to entertain 30 frat boys at once. Well, not exactly at once but more than one at a time. I’m not sure when the Molly got put into the beer, but I had a few cups before I felt extra hot and extra bothered. And when that happened, I found myself on all fours sucking two frat boy cocks, jerking, two more off, with one in my ass and one in my pussy. It felt like competing in the sex Olympics because I could hear people cheering me on.

Nothing Like a Mommy Daughter Gang Bang

And I do my best fucking with an audience. Apparently, so does my daughter. We became a gang bang duo. But before long, a few other coeds joined us. I think the Molly hit them too. Instead of smelling like stale beer, that frat house smelled like fresh pussy. And that’s an intoxicating smell to frat boys.

Ten girls took care of about 40 frat boys. What a good introduction to frat boy life for the pledges, right? A gang bang with a mommy and her daughter. I’m sure that doesn’t happen at every frat house. I’ve always enjoyed group sex. But when I can enjoy it with my daughter and her friends, it makes it even better.

When we got back to my hotel room, my daughter and I cleaned each other up with our tongues. And we fell asleep in the 69 position. Woke up, realizing we still had more cum inside of us and ate each other some more. When she graduates, I’m going to miss these wild times I get to share with her.

Kinky Phone Sex Gets Old Dicks Hard Again

kinky phone sexI’m all about kinky phone sex adventures. I make kinky memories weekly. Sometimes daily. My husband suffers from dick issues. Of course he’s in his 70s now. I married an older man. His dick size has never been the issue. But some time when he hit his 60s, his dick started to fail him when he needed it most. So, we explored different ways to help him maintain an erection. Early on when my husband experience dick issues, Viagra worked. But I never had the patience to wait until it kicked in.

So, I would take a lover in the meantime. Then we discovered that my husband enjoyed watching me with other men. It seemed to be the best aphrodisiac. And it appeared to work a lot quicker than Viagra. So, for the longest time, watching me fuck men and boys, helped my husband get hard. I cuckolded him. He sat in the corner, stroking his cock watching his hot phone sex MILF wife in action. And I have always enjoyed men watching me.

Men sometimes don’t like my husband watching. However, boys never care. You would think they would be the ones weirded out with an old guy watching and beating his dick as they fucked that old man’s wife. But it’s older men in their 40s and above that take issue with my husband watching. But good for me I prefer to fuck young men anyway.

When You Marry an Older Man You Get Creative on How to Get His Old Dick Hard

So, for the longest time, that’s how I got my husband‘s dick hard. However, like everything else he has plateaued out of even watching. But my husband is not ready to give up on his dick yet. And honestly, I’m not either. So, I investigated new ways to get my old man’s old dick hard. And I learned how to give a prostate massage.

 I think that’s just what you must do when you marry an older man, and you stay together for over 30 years. You take care of his dick one way or another. Last night we had a date night. I love that he still likes to take me out. We have a tradition of fucking after date night. Like I’ve said before he never minds me fucking younger guys. He knows I love him and I will never leave him. But I like his cock. When it works, that is.

Dick Issues? I Have Ways of Making You Cum

After date night, I dipped my finger into a jar of Vaseline and wriggled my finger up his ass. And I forced that erection. However, soon as my finger came out of his ass, his cock deflated again. So, I decided to get out the strap on I use to fuck my daughter with and fuck my husband’s ass. And what a difference that made.

I think my strap on might be my husband’s new phone sex addiction. Of course, I reached around and jacked his dick as I fucked his ass. I am a good wife after all. My old man came so much he thought he was 20 again. But I’m sure he had a lot of backed up cum. I’m sure

My Phone Perverts Paradise: Everyone is Welcum

phone perverts paradiseWelcome to the phone perverts paradise. Everybody is welcome. And every fetish is welcome too as I have no limits. My daughter went back to college. And she wanted me to come visit her to hit up some back-to-school keg parties. I always go to a party with coeds and frat boys. Honestly, they love having this dirty old MILF.  I’m sort of the life of the party.

I have introduced them to a lot of things. And they introduced me to Molly. Although I smoked a lot of pot, done my share of cocaine, and drank quite a bit of alcohol in my day, but no Molly until my first frat party. It’s surpassed poppers as the new sex drug. Not that young people need drugs to fuck. They still seem naturally horny. But the Molly brings out the freak in them all.

This phone sex MILF turns into a gang bang whore on Molly. I’m not shy in general. But I guess I had never really had a gang bang until I started going to frat parties with my daughter. I’ve had my share of threesomes and many orgies. But 30 frat brothers running a train on me never happened until I took Molly for the first time.

This Friday night, my daughter counted 50 frat brothers, including a bunch of new pledges who fucked me. I remember the gang bang, but I lost count. Some of those fat boys start to look the same after a while. I just love having all that young cock to myself.

This Horny Cougar Lives for Frat Boy Gang Bangs

Other coeds watched. Some watched in fear that they would be next. But I assured those girls nobody had to get gang banged unless they wanted to be gang banged. Because the apple does not fall far from the tree, my daughter wanted to get gang banged too. So, she got on all fours next to her proud mama and took care of the guys too impatient to wait their turn.

By the time, my daughter and I got back to my Airbnb that I rented for the weekend, we looked like porn stars. We both appeared covered in cum from head to toe. But I don’t mind. And neither does she. We are about as close as a mother and daughter can be. We literally share everything, especially cum. But wee were not ready to end the night quite yet. So, we spent some time cleaning the mess up. I licked all the cum off her and from inside of her pussy and ass too. And she did the same for me.

The sexy mommy had the hottest phone sex weekend with her daughter. And I can’t wait to go back a few more times. I’m going to make the best of it because she will graduate next year and that means no more frat party gang bangs for this sexy MILF.

Fetish Phone Sex Calls Arouse Me Still

fetish phone sexFetish phone sex calls vary with me. As a mature woman, I can cater to anything. I have a few of my own. Although the main fetish I cater to and my most popular request is cuckolding. But I enjoy feet fetishes too. And shoes and pantyhose. I met a man with a foot fetish earlier in the week. We needed a plumber for the kitchen sink. My husband hired this outfit we use often. A family business. Local guys who have long taken care of us.

Usually, the dad is the one that comes over. But he sent his son-in-law this time. My guess mid-30s. I sat on a kitchen counter making small talk with him. He seemed nervous. But I quickly realized he liked my feet. In the house, I am barefoot. As a phone sex milf, I know when boys stare at my tits. And I know when men check out my feet. I stretched my legs out, arching my feet to test my hypothesis. And he took the bait.

My Pretty Feet Love a Nice Cock

So, I told him he could caress my feet. I was letting him warm up. I could see a huge bulge in his coveralls. Although I have never been inappropriate with the plumber. This was not our usual guy. This was a young buff man with a big cock. When he started caressing my feet, I gradually worked my foot closer to his crotch. And eventually, I felt his cock twitch under my foot. All I had to do was suggest he put his throbbing cock between my feet and out came his snake. Both my freshly pedicured feet wrapped around his cock.

My feet know how to give a foot job. Been awhile, but it is like riding a bike. You do not forget how to do. The poor boy could not look me in the eyes. He focused on my feet. And I focused on his beautiful cock.  Eventually, his cock came. His jizz poured between my toes like a waterfall. I did something that shocked us both. I put my foot to my mouth and sucked his cum off my toes.

But I enjoyed this kinky phone sex encounter. He fixed the sink. Put his cock away and thanked me. Then I gave him a glowing review to his father-in-law.